The company premises as passport
An analysis of the company photos of two post-war Belgian building contractors
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.48003/knob.122.2023.3.791Downloads
Abstract
In several academic disciplines that focus on (historical) building practice there is growing interest in building contractors and their employees. Their contribution and influence are increasingly the subject of research. After the Second World War the contractor’s field of work was defined by productivity, specialization and industrialization, which profoundly altered the professional character of this branch of industry. Social developments and the prevailing idea of an all-encompassing welfare state triggered top-down and bottom-up changes in this traditionally highly cyclical sector. This fostered diversity in the contracting world, yet those diverse profiles and identities often remain unrecognized today. This is compounded by the fact that, unlike architects for example, the source material left behind by contractors and their employees is usually less informative and often fragmented.
This article seeks to demonstrate the potential of alternative source material by analysing company photos in order to better understand the profile and identity of two post-war Belgian contractors. During their existence, Van Coillie of Oostende (1919-1976) and Van Laere of Kruibeke (1938-1989) amassed extensive collections of photographs, which were recently made accessible by the Flanders Architecture Institute (VAi). The focus of this article is on a series of photos from the 1960s and ’70s depicting the headquarters of both companies. These company premises and buildings were the very heart of the businesses, which adopted a pragmatic or strategic design to reflect their profile and identity. The selected photos are compared with information gleaned from a series of in-depth interviews with ex-employees in order to place the companies in their particular historical context.
The analysis is in two parts, the first of which focuses on the site, the company architecture and the implanting. This reveals information about the size and organization of the contractors, as well as about their company strategy and professional profile. For example, they used these elements to create a strong position in the building sector and in so doing cement their reputation. The second part analyses a few interiors of the 1961 Van Laere headquarters. A detailed visual examination reveals how these spaces reflected the internal organization and hierarchical structure and how Van Laere projected its company image both internally and externally. The pictures also chart the development of an organizational culture and a body of values and norms that in turn shaped the company identity. The company management, the internal organization and the social and local network in which the firms were embedded, consequently had a considerable effect on the position they occupied as individual players in building practice. The main finding from these two analyses is that these post-war construction players were highly diverse. A critical and biographical sketch in terms of activities, profile and identity is consequently a necessary starting point for a detailed analysis of their position and role within national and international post-war building practice. This article shows what a rich source photographic material can be in developing such a sketch.
References
B. Latour en A. Yaneva, ‘Give Me a Gun and I Will Make All Buildings Move. An ANT’s View of Architecture’, Ardeth 8 (2017) 1, 107.
Zie onder meer de these van Antoine Picon, die erop wees dat de praktijk van het bouwen niet enkel een technische constructie is maar ook een sociale constructie, wat invloedrijk was binnen het onderzoeksveld: A. Picon, ‘Construction history. Between technological and cultural history’, Construction History 21 (2006), 5-19.
P. Lombaerde, Bouwen is leven, leven is bouwen, Brussel 1996, 8-147.
Zie bijvoorbeeld het werk van Christine Wall over de veranderende verhoudingen tussen ontwerpers en uitvoerders in de Britse naoorlogse context: C. Wall, An architecture of parts. Architects, building workers and industrialisation in Britain 1940-1970, Londen/New York 2013.
J. Angillis, S. Van de Voorde en I. Bertels, ‘Building a profile? Belgian general contractor Van Coillie and its construction activities in the 1960s’, in: J. Campbell (red.) Studies in Construction History. The Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Conference of the Construction History Society, Cambridge 2023.
S. De Caigny, E. Buyst en C. Vancoppenolle, ‘Heuristiek en methode. De (on)mogelijkheid van bedrijfsgeschiedenis in België, 19de-20ste eeuw’, Belgisch Tijdschrift voor Nieuwste Geschiedenis 33 (2003) 3-4, 319-356.
J. Dobbels, ‘Aannemersarchieven onder de loep. Analyse van de bruikbaarheid voor de erfgoedsector’, M&L. Monumenten, Landschappen en Archeologie 38 (2020) 1, 4-26.
C. Wall, ‘Recording the “building world”. How oral history transforms construction history’, in: J. Campbell e.a., The First Construction History Society Conference & Annual General Meeting, Cambridge 2014, 435-444.
Zie in verband met Oral History bijvoorbeeld: J. Gosseye, N. Stead en D. Van der Plaat (red.), Speaking of buildings. Oral history in architectural research, New York 2019. Zie in verband met visuele analyse bijvoorbeeld: M. Chrimes, Civil engineering, 1839-1889. A photographic history, New Hampshire 1992; G. Delhumeau (red.), Le béton en représentation. La mémoire photographique de l’entreprise Hennebique, 1890-1930, Parijs 1993; A. Presland, Picturing Construction, Constructing Identities. The Photographic Archive of John Laing & Son Ltd (doctoraatsthesis), Londen 2023.
J. Paskins, ‘Constructing Work. Politics, society and architectural history on the Paris building site’, in: D.J. Sage en C. Vitry (red.), Societies under construction. Geographies, sociologies and histories of building, Cham 2018, 105.
Pvba Van Coillie was in 1976 genoodzaakt het faillissement aan te vragen na een jarenlang dispuut met de Belgische fiscus. NV Van Laere werd in 1989 overgenomen door Groep Ackermans & van Haaren. Momenteel is Van Laere ondergebracht bij het AvH-dochterbedrijf CFE Contracting. Kort na de overname in 1989 verlieten vrijwel alle Van Laere-familieleden het bedrijf.
Vlaams Architectuurinstituut, Archief Van Coillie, V.R. en J., ref. BE/653717/0123-VC; Vlaams Architectuurinstituut, Beeldarchief van bouwbedrijf Van Laere, ref. BE/653717/0189-VLA; zie ook: J. Angillis ‘The post-war construction site in photographs. The photographic collection of the Belgian contractor firm Van Laere (°1938)’, in: J. Mascarenhas-Mateus (red.), History of construction cultures, Leiden 2021, 447- 457.
P. Burke, Eyewitnessing. The uses of images as historical evidence, New York 2008, 14-15.
G. Rose, Visual methodologies. An introduction to researching with visual materials, Londen 2016.
S. Van de Voorde en R. Devos, ‘Business-card buildings. Corporate architecture and promotional strategies in buildings and projects for Eternit in Belgium (1955–75)’, in I. Wouters e.a. (red.), Building Knowledge, Constructing Histories, 2 vols., Londen 2018; L. Raaffels e.a., ‘Visitekaartjes in steen, hout en beton. De eigen woning van de architect als commercieel instrument’, Bulletin KNOB 119 (2020) 2, 1-22.
Van de Voorde en Devos 2018 (noot 15), 1308-9.
A. Thomas, ‘Women, work and the office’, in: M. Bovens (red.), De toekomst van het (samen) werken. Advies over de kantoorportefeuille van de rijksoverheid, [Den Haag] 2022, 28-31.
F. Le Cam, ‘Photographs of newsrooms. From the printing house to open space offices. Analyzing the transformation of workspaces and information production’, Journalism 16 (2015) 1, 134-152.
J. Van Coillie, De zaak Van Coillie. Een schitterende Fiscale Blunder, Tielt 1998, 1-43.
H. Beyers, ‘Bezoek aan Algemene aannemingen “Van Laere” p.v.b.a.’, Interimkantoor voor de 3e leeftijd, april 1974.
J. Dobbels, Building a profession. A history of general contractors in Belgium (1870-1970), Brussel 2022.
De ‘I’ in IPAN stond voor de schrijnwerkerij August Ingelbrecht & Cie., die in 1955 samen met haar 25 werknemers door Van Coillie werd overgenomen. ‘PAN’ was een verwijzing naar hun eigen wand- en moduleplafondsysteem bestaande uit metalen profielen en panelen.
J. Van Coillie, nakomeling bedrijfsleider Victor Van Coillie, geïnterviewd door auteur, 15 december 2022.
L. De Visch, schrijnwerker en medewerker IPAN, geïnterviewd door auteur, 13 februari 2023.
J. Van Coillie, ‘De Bedrijfsleiding aan het woord: IPAN’, De Schakel 1 (1962) 3.
J. Van Coillie 1998 (noot 19), 22.
‘Le vitrage abondant dans la partie basse des façades permet aux ouvriers de s’inspirer de la beauté du paysage environnant, pendant l’exécution de leur tâche journalière.’ W. Bresseleers, ‘Usine Ipan à Stene/Ostende’, Architecture 62 46 (1962), 179-80.
J. Van Coillie 1998 (noot 19), 22.
PVBA Van Coillie, Bouwbedrijf Van Coillie, 50 jaar bouwen – dynamisch en merkwaardig, Oostende 1969, 10.
H. Van Laere, aandeelhouder en werfleider, geïnterviewd door auteur, 1 oktober 2020; H. Van Laere, aandeelhouder en werfleider, geïnterviewd door auteur, 3 november 2020.
R. Gyselinck, archivaris Van Laere, geïnterviewd door auteur, 15 februari 2022.
Van Coillie 15 december 2022 (noot 23); G. Welvaert, secretaresse Van Coillie, geïnterviewd door auteur, 19 december 2022; Gyselinck 15 februari 2022 (noot 31).
Bresseleers 1962 (noot 27), 180.
Zie onder andere: M. Versichelen, Verlaten beroepen? Oorzaken en achtergronden van het aanhoudend tekort aan arbeidskrachten in de bouwnijverheid, Gent 1969.
Gyselinck 15 februari 2022 (noot 31).
L. Anné, schrijnwerker Van Laere, geïnterviewd door auteur, 12 januari 2022.
E. Edwards en J. Hart (red.), Photographs objects histories. On the materiality of images, London en New York 2004.
Gyselinck 15 februari 2022 (noot 31).
A. Blombäck en O. Brunninge, ‘Corporate Identity Manifested through Historical References’, Corporate Communications. An International Journal 14 (2009) 4, 410-411.
E. Gutheny en J. Brad, ‘CEO Portraits and the Authenticity Paradox’, Journal of Management Studies 42 (2005), 1057-1058.
Blombäck en Brunninge 2009 (noot 39), 410.
Van Laere 1 oktober 2020 (noot 30); Van Laere 3 november 2020 (noot 30).
W. Gibb Dyer, ‘Culture and continuity in family firms’, Family Business Review 1 (1988) 1, 18-20.
Gyselinck 15 februari 2022 (noot 31).
A. Monjaret, ‘Les bureaux ne sont pas seulement des espaces de travail…’, Communication et organisation, 21 (2002), 5.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Jelle Angillis
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.